Wednesday

Large classes: basic guidelines

There are four major requirements to work with large classes:

1. Well defined expectation right at the beginning of the course from first day of classes
2. Decrease anonymity by forming personal relationships with students
3. Encourage active learning
4. Self-assessment of teaching and class behavior from students and peer faculty

1. Define expectations

The first class meeting needs to be welcoming and informing about class expectations concerning attendance, tardiness, chatter, class dismissal, etc. A clear and very informative (read it “detailed”) syllabus can reduce student confusion about appropriate behavior and learning expectations. Students should realize that they are partners in the teaching and learning process and the responsibility is not fully on the teacher’s shoulders. Learning outcomes statements should be included in a typical course syllabus. Students must know how what skills they are supposed to be able to demonstrate by the end of the course and how they are going to be measured. Awareness that participation and attendance are two different things and how they will be measured. Any details about readings, quizzes, tests, homework, grading issues etc. Especially for very large classes details are very important to be spelled out in the syllabus and in the first day of classes. Students have a right to know what they will be able to do when they complete a certain course and should know what they’ll need to know for the next course.

Especially for the first day of class, recommended for each class, is good to keep a short check list. This will help you keep track of everything you intend to do or tell your students. At times there are diverse distracters in a class and you might forget one very important note for the upcoming exam, the check list will help you deliver that message even if the class took a different direction than first planned.

2. Decrease anonymity

Civility is increased when a student creates a personal relationship with the teacher or fellow students. The easiest way to create a personal relationship is by learning student names (however some teachers find this task very difficult).

One other way to make a personal relationship with different groups of students is to administer a background questionnaire asking students to list their home town, which student residence they live in, what is their major, why are they taking the course, extracurricular interests, first born, or number of siblings, if they are athlete students, etc. Collect the index cards with responses and tally the responses. Next class time list the different groups and ask students to stand up and let them cheer each other, or use the groups to ask questions from the particular groups, and use the personal interests or experiences as example background to draw their interest.
Instead of having office hours in the teacher’s office – which is a very hard task to have when one teaches 400 students and might be before exams 100 students wait in line – have the office hours in a empty classroom, if no blackboard is needed or if laptops are available the meeting can be held outdoors on the class web site. Encourage students to come for office hour discussions, and share their questions. It is always a good idea to use computers so the Q & A session can be recorded and posted on the class web site for the other ones who could not make it to the office hour session but might have the same question.

Later is a good idea to save the Q&A in a document and post it on the class web for future semesters. It is most likely that future generation of students will have the same questions. Always organize the Q&A document on topics.

3. Encourage active learning

Even in very large classes active learning is possible. A short class assignment (no more than 5 minutes of class time) will increase student learning.

In order to increase attention to the lecture, break down the hour lecture with short time active learning tasks.

Teaching strategies to be used in large and small classes:

- Think-pair-share

- Minute paper

- Formative quizzes

- Associational brainstorming

- Evocative visuals or textual passages

- Debates

- Role-playing

- Mini-Cases

In order to be efficient in using active learning in large classes follow the below guidelines:

a. Use only a short and specific task (e.g., List the most important points we discussed so far; List as many concepts as you can from the new ones learned in this lecture), and always post on the board clear written directions (oral directions can be confusing or not well heard)

b. Encourage participation by requiring that hand-outs or flashcard responses be turned in

c. Maintain order by limiting the time and number of members in the group

4. Self-assessment of teaching behavior - in general student evaluation from large classes list concerns about lecturing behavior such as talking too fast or too slow, too softly, writing too fast or blocking the blackboard, talking down, being unhelpful, employing confusing words on the examinations, and confusing grading practices. Unfortunately the course evaluations are presented to the teacher long after the semester has ended, in this situation the teacher cannot change anything in the teaching process of past semester.

Remember that students must know what they are expected they will be able to do by the end of the course and how they are going to be measured. Always list the learning outcomes clearly in the syllabus and stress in the first day of class the expectations and ground rules set forth in the course for a successful teacher-student collaboration and successful learning experience. Students always appreciate if you see them as responsible adults and active participants in the learning process.

However it is not enough to have good syllabus and ground rules, each teacher must be in tune with the flow of that certain class of students. One effective technique is to administer an informal course evaluation early in the semester so you can have a clear picture of how the class is going and still enough time to bring eventual changes.
The course evaluation to be most efficient should be administered by a neutral person (Faculty development and Assessment centers usually assist in this matter). The instructor of the course can set the questions of interest in the course evaluation. Questions should group in three major groups:

- What do students most like about the course and teaching?

- What they would like to see changed or improved?

- What would make the course a better learning experience? Offer suggestions to improve/change.

Another modality (especially for very large classes) is to use Small Group Instructional Diagnosis (SGID) conducted by a specialist from the university Faculty development & Assessment Center, or conducted by a well seasoned colleague professor that has training and tact and does not teach the respective cohort of students in order to be neutral and not intimidate students’ responses.

Self evaluation can be conducted also by having a colleague faculty do a peer consulting. Peer Consultants are trained support colleagues who engage in a full range of consultation services as related to teaching, instruction, classroom assessment practices, and the scholarship of teaching. Peer Consultant activities include classroom observations, conducting focus groups, reviewing teaching evaluations, reviewing the syllabus, and counseling faculty colleagues in a supportive, confidential and nonjudgmental manner.

Teaching large classes

  • Many instructors who teach large classes think that they can use the same techniques as when they teach regular sized classes. However, the rule “more of the same” does not apply when instructors work with large student body.

  • There are teaching techniques as well as class management issues that apply best to large sized classes.
  • Those who teach for the first time a large class usually think that general teaching techniques and class management rules that are used in teaching average sized classes are also safe to be used in large classes. Novice instructors for large classes think the only difference is that one teaches the same way but in front of more students. Often that is not true, and novice instructors learn this very soon. The rule “more of the same” does not apply in teaching large classes. An instructor feels safe and can enter in front of 20 to 40 students in the first day of class with a half completed syllabus. The same instructor can brush of the student who asks the question about when exactly will be the first due date. However in a large class (anywhere above 100 students), the same question will create a tornado of problems if the syllabus does not present clear rules and responses to common class management questions. To teach well a large class requires from the instructor good organization skills.
  • Teaching large classes requires preparation and good strategies. No matter what is the teaching style of an instructor, when she or he comes into a large class the essential is to have a clear syllabus, good planning, and a good handle on classroom management and organization. If in a class of 40-50 one is able to shift ground rules in the middle of the semester, this becomes an extreme effort, or a complete disaster when in class are close to 400-500 students. When working with large classes the instructor must think and adapt her or his teaching techniques appropriately.


Syllabus with Bloom Taxonomy

A syllabus is a planning tool for course purposes. It helps the instructor to organize the course, define goals and student learning outcomes, and plan the course assessment and the calendar. The syllabus is also a guide for the students who take the respective course. It should communicate in a clear and detailed manner the course content, teaching approaches, requirements, and expectations in the course. Since the syllabus is a document that communicates with a larger audience (colleagues, administrators, accreditation agencies) it is also a reference guide.

In the process of planning the course and building the syllabus the instructor must decide which topics will be covered in the course, and for each what is the expected learning level that will be demonstrated by the students. Based on that decision the instructor will plan appropriate assessment measures. The purpose is to have a good balance of learning outcomes adequate to the importance of the different topics taught by the instructor. The instructor is the one who decides on which topic students should demonstrate a higher levels of thinking and the instructor would plan accordingly the appropriate assessment measure for the respective levels.

A very useful tool in planning for expected levels of teaching, learning, and assessment is the table of Bloom’s taxonomy. Bloom’s taxonomy gives a useful guide to map out the instructor’s plans for the course and provides an easy way to think about appropriate assessment tools. Bloom’s revised taxonomy defines learning as a two dimensional process: cognitive and knowledge based. This takes into account the learners’ thinking and knowledge based abilities.

Bloom classified the cognitive skills in six levels from lower (remembering, understanding, and lower level of applying) to higher levels of thinking (applying, analyzing, evaluating, and creating). Below in this document you will find detailed descriptions for each level.

When planning activities and assessment for course purposes the first step the instructor would take is to map out each topic studied in the course at the desired level of thinking and knowledge. Then the next step the instructor would derive the learning outcomes and matching assessment type for each topic.

Learning outcomes objectives (what the instructor plans that students will know or demonstrate by the end of the course) can be classified under one of the six levels of the cognitive process dimension, and under one of the four categories under the knowledge dimension of the table.

For example the instructor thinking of a specific theory that will be taught in the course has as goal that students are able to use the theory and analyze the provided information. In the same time the instructor would like to have students be able to show this ability in writing. This goal would map in Bloom’s taxonomy in the cognitive dimension under “Analyzing” and the ability to demonstrate in practice would fall under “Procedural” knowledge dimension.

Then in order to satisfy the two choices the instructor would design an assignment where students would be required to do a data analysis and write a report of findings.

In the syllabus under the Learning Outcomes section this goal would be:

“Students will be able to analyze given data sets and write a report on the findings.”


In order to plan learning outcomes and measure student learning based on learning outcomes we need to plan for the appropriate assessment.

Below are descriptors for each of the cognitive levels and a list of questions to think about in designing the appropriate assessment for each level.

CATEGORIES of COGNITIVE PROCESS


Remembering
Retrieve relevant knowledge from long-term memory

RECOGNIZING (identifying)

RECALLING (retrieving)

Understanding
Construct meaning from instructional messages, including oral, written,

and graphic communication

INTERPRETING (clarifying, paraphrasing, representing, translating)

EXEMPLIFYING (illustrating, instantiating)

CLASSIFYING (categorizing, subsuming)

SUMMARIZING (abstracting, generalizing)

INFERRING (concluding, extrapolating, interpolating, predicting)

COMPARING (contrasting, mapping, matching)

EXPLAINING (constructing models)


Applying
Carry out or use a procedure in a given situation

EXECUTING (carrying out)

IMPLEMENTING (using)


Analyzing
Break material into its constituent parts and determine how the parts

relate to one another and to an overall structure or purpose

DIFFERENTIATING (discriminating, distinguishing, focusing, selecting)

ORGANIZING (finding coherence, intergrating, outlining, parsing, structuring)

ATTRIBUTING (deconstructing)


Evaluating
Make judgments based on criteria and standards

CHECKING (coordinating, detecting, monitoring, testing

CRITIQUING (judging)


Creating
Put elements together to form a coherent or functional whole; reorganize

elements into a new pattern or structure

GENERATING (hypothesizing)

PLANNING (designing)

PRODUCING (constructing)



KNOWLEDGE DIMENSIONS:

Factual Knowledge is knowledge that is basic to specific disciplines. This dimension refers to essential facts, terminology, details or elements students must know or be familiar with in order to understand a discipline or solve a problem in it.

Conceptual Knowledge is knowledge of classifications, principles, generalizations, theories, models, or structures pertinent to a particular disciplinary area.

Procedural Knowledge refers to information or knowledge that helps students to do something specific to a discipline, subject, or area of study. It also refers to methods of inquiry, very specific or finite skills, algorithms, techniques, and particular methodologies.

Metacognitive Knowledge is the awareness of one’s own cognition and particular cognitive processes. It is strategic or reflective knowledge about how to go about solving problems, perform cognitive tasks, to include contextual and conditional knowledge and knowledge of self.




References

Anderson, L.W. & Krathwohl, D.R. (Eds.) (2001). A taxonomy for Learning, teaching, and assessing: A revision of Bloom’s taxonomy of educational objectives. New York: Addison Wesley Longman.


Bloom, B.S. (Ed.), Engelhart, M.D., Furst, E.J., Hill, W.H., & Krathwohl, D.R. (1956).

Taxonomy of educational objectives: Handbook I: Cognitive domain. New York: David McKay.

Bloom's taxonomy to your help

Syllabus with Learning Outcomes

One useful tool (but not the only one) to be used when planning and designing a course syllabus, assessment, and the different levels of content you will present in the lectures is Bloom's taxonomy.

Bloom's revised taxonomy is a easy and simple enough tool to map out the different levels of knowledge and cognition that you intend your students to demonstrate once they go through your course.

Start by collecting the topics you intend to teach, then think about what are the important skills you would like your students to have once they complete successfully your course. Think in terms of student skills, competencies, procedural knowledge as demonstrated by your students once they complete successfully your course.

Often when we write course outcomes we have the tendency to list the course content (the list of topics, or chapters students will learn), or a description of what students will learn in the course or a description of mathods and assessment tools we use. All those are good to know, however Student Learning Outcomes should be thought of and written having in mind students' skills. Think about student doing something not what the course content is or the teacher does in the class.


Quick tip: Syllabus

A syllabus is a planning tool for course purposes. It helps the instructor to organize the course, define goals and student learning outcomes, and plan the course assessment and the calendar. The syllabus is also a guide for the students who take the respective course. It should communicate in a clear and detailed manner the course content, teaching approaches, requirements, and expectations in the course. Since the syllabus is a document that communicates with a larger audience (colleagues, administrators, accreditation agencies) it is also a reference guide.

In the process of planning the course and building the syllabus the instructor must decide which topics will be covered in the course, and for each what is the expected learning level that will be demonstrated by the students. Based on that decision the instructor will plan appropriate assessment measures. The purpose is to have a good balance of learning outcomes adequate to the importance of the different topics taught by the instructor. The instructor is the one who decides on which topic students should demonstrate a higher levels of thinking and the instructor would plan accordingly the appropriate assessment measure for the respective levels.

A very useful tool in planning for expected levels of teaching, learning, and assessment is the table of Bloom’s taxonomy. Bloom’s taxonomy gives a useful guide to map out the instructor’s plans for the course and provides an easy way to think about appropriate assessment tools. Bloom’s revised taxonomy defines learning as a two dimensional process: cognitive and knowledge based. This takes into account the learners’ thinking and knowledge based abilities.

Bloom classified the cognitive skills in six levels from lower (remembering, understanding, and lower level of applying) to higher levels of thinking (applying, analyzing, evaluating, and creating). Below in this document you will find detailed descriptions for each level.

When planning activities and assessment for course purposes the first step the instructor would take is to map out each topic studied in the course at the desired level of thinking and knowledge. Then the next step the instructor would derive the learning outcomes and matching assessment type for each topic.