Tuesday

Minute Paper --- template

In concise, well-planned sentences, please answer the two questions below:


1. What are the two most meaningful things you have learned from the topic we learned in the class today?



2. What is that one question that remains in your mind and you would like to have more information on?

-------------

More teaching strategies to be found in:

Angelo, T. A., & Cross, K. P. (1993). Classroom assessment techniques: A handbook for college teachers. (2nd ed.). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Discipline in Large Classes

* TALKING AND INNATENTION

- Make direct eye contact with those who talk so they know you noticed them

- Physically move in proximity of those who talk

- Ask a direct question to the area where they are seated

- Call offending student to remain a minute after class and make a private remark (usually students appreciate when they are not embarrassed in public)

- If you ever have comments in the course evaluations from past courses where students complain of their peers it is a good idea to read those in the first day of class, this creates peer pressure. Also make everyone know that you appreciate if they bring to your awareness that there are peers who disturb the learning process (this creates as well a peer pressure and minimizes misbehavior).

* ARRIVING LATE OR LEAVING EARLY

- Spell clearly the ground rule in the syllabus, explain in the first day of class and let students know that you expect them to come to class on time and in return you will start and finish as scheduled.

- Have a starting ritual: dim the lights before you start talking, play music, ask a group of students in the front row to clap all at once so it draws everyone’s attention, read a joke or a quote of the day, etc.

- Require students to inform you verbally or in writing if they need to arrive or leave early (due to conflict or tight schedule of classes in other buildings) possibly you can reserve a special space in the front or the back of class so they do not disturb the teaching process

- Station the TAs along the back of the classroom and approach those who leave early and ask them what is the reason or if they are okay, why are they leaving, etc.

- Post on the board in the last 5 minutes of the lecture a topic or a question to conclude the teaching of the day and preview the next topic. It is useful to have similar questions on the exam, that way students will be less tempted to leave.

- Let students know that there are costs for arriving late or leaving early; you do not teach two times the same topic, gather assignments in the first 5 minutes or take sporadic attendance in the last 5 minutes of class time by having each student exit the door by turning in one flash card with their name on it. Post TAs at each exit. That way students cannot turn in multiple names at once.

* INNATENDANCE

- Attendance and Participation are different things. Attendance is physical presence, as opposed to participation which involves physical presence but it is not limited to that only. Participation supposes active behavior of being involved in the teaching and learning process that take place in the classroom. If you require attendance then be sure to have a measure for it. Collecting homework, in-class assignments that are collected at the end of the class, a quiz at the end of the class, one minute paper, flash card with name and response to a question on “Muddiest point” (what was the most difficult concept, or topic, a question that remains after today’s lecture).

- A good system to take attendance is by using a extra credit system by having 10 short quizzes at unannounced times in the semester. This will measure attendance and encourage students to be present to your class since most students like to have the extra credit opportunity. You also measure learning in that class time and is a good way to see how your students understand the topics you teach.

- Some students who have lecture notes online consider that notes are sufficient to prepare for exams. Make sure that your students understand the connection between having the notes available upfront and participating in the lecture by learning the application of the concepts. For this reason it is always good to use many examples and practical application in the classroom which clarify the lecture notes posted on the class web, or the text provided in the textbook.

- A good modality to make students aware that you pay attention to their presence in the classroom is to ask them on exam day (when attendance is high) to write on a piece of paper (no names provided) the reason why they missed, or would miss a class, or why they do not attend classes regularly.

* DEADLINES

- The syllabus must present clear statement concerning missed exams, make-up exams, turn in late papers or late homework. Over the semester periodically refer to your policies since students tend to forget and do not pay attention to what is stated in the syllabus.

- If you have clear policies stated in the syllabus, make sure you explain the reason in the first day of classes. Do not make any exceptions from your rules unless in extraordinary circumstances and then in private. Always explain and document the rationale of any policy changes.

- You also must keep the deadlines. If you promise your students that you will turn in the grades at a certain date then do so.

Teaching strategies

Teaching strategies to be used in large and small classes

- Associational brainstorming – very good method to start a class or introduce a new topic/concept. Invite students to brainstorm everything it comes to mind related to the concept or word that represents a new topic. Encourage students to list Cognitive and Affective relations that come to their mind. Make sure you record all ideas – everything is good without any judgmental comment, let them do free association. Use a slide or overhead to collect all ideas. Then try to group the recorded ideas and ask students to come up with further groupings and reasons for the groups, and ask them to name the categories. Ask students to analyze the collected responses and identify themes, categories, connections, and patterns.

- Evocative visuals or textual passages – Good method to start the course, or a new topic. Start out with a picture, painting, or a video clip, or choose a powerful text passage, a chart, a graph that represents a content that you will teach. Ask the students to brainstorm their analysis of the presented. Ask questions to start the discussion: “What do you see?” “What is going on?” “What does it mean to you?” “What do you think it this?” “Why do you think I showed this to you?” “How do you think this relates to what you are studying in this class?” Use pairs or small groups (students seated in proximity) to let students share their representations then regroup as an class and ask them to comment. Several different ideas will arise. Provide support and challenge, model your way of thinking about the presented. Easily direct the flow of though toward the concept/topic you will teach next.

- Debates – good method to exemplify different ways of solving/ thinking about a problem, as well as to demonstrate higher order thinking and problem solving skills. The way students are seated divide the class in several areas (possibly as many ways of seeing a problem can be). Ask the large groups to think from the different perspectives and come up with arguments to defend that way of thinking. Give students 5 minutes to discuss in pairs or proximity seating small groups then call the class to regroup and ask the different parts to volunteer with examples of their way of thinking. If you use this to debate pro –con topic then is good at least to have a third group who must not take any side and come up with reasons why they would abstain to be for or against.

- Role-playing – very good method for History, Literature, or Biochemistry classes. Divide the class into as many sections as you need to have for role playing. Ask them to prepare their arguments or plan their behavior representing the role they play (different characters of a play, different groups in history, different enzymes that could react and form new ones). Give examples of content and then ask student to discuss shortly in pairs or small groups how would their role react. Then ask as an entire class to have representative descriptions from each section. Draw attention to consequences of possibly unplanned behavior descriptions and compare with the reality of the lecture you teach.

- Mini-Cases – can be used as a start up for a lecture or spread in between to spice up the tempo of the longer lectures and help students better understand by using a specific example. Students can be asked to pair up or form small groups turning around to colleagues seated in proximity. One group presents the case to the entire class then pairs/ small groups work for several minutes to find responses by directly applying the content to the case example.

- Think-pair-share – Ask a question to interrupt the lecture after approx 15-20 minutes, ask student to write down the response to the question, then turn to the next neighbor and discuss the responses. No more than 5 minutes (depends on the complexity of the question); then ask several pairs to share their responses and conclude with a correct response and move to the next topic in the lecture

- Minute paper – is a very powerful way to assess the degree students understand the topics and concepts they studied in the respective class period. Can be used 20 minutes in the lecture or at the end of the class. The task should not take more than 5 minutes maximum of class time. If it is used in the middle of the lecture then some questions might be: “Explain shortly the main concept discussed in this part of the lecture,” “Give an example of this concept or principle,” “How could this concept apply to…” a possible next topic in the same lecture, “How does this idea relate to your experience with…?” used at the end of the class period the One minute paper questions are: “1. What are the most important things you learned in today’s lecture? 2. What is the question on today’s topic that remains in your mind after this lecture?” Collect the responses – this is also a good way to take attendance if you request names (however names might affect honest statements of questions from students). The collected can form a basis for next class starting 5 minutes. Possibly you need to revise a concept, give some examples, or clarify some topics. Also you can use it as a basis to give good examples.

- Pause procedure – ask student in pair or group with 2-3 other students seated in proximity to compare notes or results from a short exercise in class. Allow 2-3 minutes and ask what questions if any arose from their review.

- Formative quizzes – quizzes that are not graded, can be used to evaluate how students understood a certain topic. Use similar questions as they will be on the exam. Use a power point slide or overheads to post the question. Responses can be shown by raising of hands. Clickers can be handy for this type of activity, unless you have a group larger than 150 where the time to get in the results from clickers takes longer than solving the problem (clickers for very large classes are not efficient).

- Focused listing - Ask students to list the concepts they learned in the past week (or half semester in preparation for Midterm, or use it as a semester end review). Along with the major concepts then ask them to shortly explain each and show on the blackboard how the concepts relate to each other. It is a good visual method to "see the big picture" and review the concepts learned so far.

- Concept map - is very similar to the one above, but this is focused on a specific concept. As someone in class to write on the blackboard the concept, then other students can come and add links to description of the concept and relation to other concepts that were studied. Very good visual representation that helps your students memory and learning for an exam; and gives them a model to use for other topics or courses.

- Misconceptions - Very good method when you introduce a new concept and from past semesters you know what kind of possible misconceptions your students bring to the class (good for Biology, Physics, Chemistry, Math, etc.). Ask the class what do they think "XXX (new concept)" is; or ask them to explain, or represent what "XXX (new concept)" is. Encourage them to explain freely, no need for specific terminology and ask the class to let everyone tell their opinion and ideas about XXX. Don't allow anyone to put down the ones who speak. List on the blackboard all the ideas, explanations, and words they use in their explanations. Then give the correct information, and ask the class to analyze why and from where one would develop the listed misconceptions. Contrast the correct information with the most incorrect one, and explain why one would hold a misconception.

- Ethical dilemma - When teaching about a controversial issue is always good to ask the class to list pro and con arguments. You also can ask half of the class to take the stand for a pro argument and the other half of class to bring arguments against it. be aware that at time this can develop into a heated discussion. It for sure brings attention and focus to the entire audience, at times you might feel like loosing the class control. If you do not feel comfortable managing the class and calming down spirits, then this is not the method to use.

- One word journal (one word chapter) - When you assign exra readings to class (or when you would like to make sure everyone did the readings) ask students (a class time ahead) to complete the One word chapter form. Students are required to read the chapter/ article/ part of readings assigned for next class time and think about the readings and come up with one word that is the most representative and would compraise the essence of readings. This word does not have to be necessarily a concept from the readings, it can be any word the student feels represents the meaning of what was read. Write the word on the form and below explain shortly why the word was choosen, and how it relates to past topics studied in the class. This will ensure that students read and thought about the readings. In class ask randomly students to tell the word and their explanation about the word. Make sure you ask several students for their word. write all new owrds on the blackboard or overhead. Then ask by hand raising that students list their words. Write any new word on the blackbaord. Start your leacture by developing and explaining the connections between those words that are posted. Is always an excellent way to start a new topic, make conncetions, and vincolve the class in the lecture topic.



More teaching strategies to be found in:

Angelo, T. A., & Cross, K. P. (1993). Classroom assessment techniques: A handbook for college teachers. (2nd ed.). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Teaching large Math classes

Teaching Mathematics courses in large classes
(applicable also for Physics, Chemistry, Engineering, Computer science, etc.)

The critical task in teaching large mathematics class is to maintain student attention with a logical presentation of the concepts, and actively involving their thinking process. There are several good strategies to be used in mathematics large classes to encourage active engagement:

1. Active practice: “Math is not a spectator sport” – give students notes sheets with space to practice the problems you teach at the blackboard. Include essential terms and formulas and ask students to fill in definitions and problems that are worked in class.

2. Time to practice: when working on a problem in class give time to your students to work on the problem individually, then ask them to compare their work with the person sitting next to them. Display your own solution or ask a student to come to the blackboard and present their results. Discuss the process and any errors and ask questions on other modalities of solving the problem and discuss the errors. One way to do this is to distribute transparencies around the room and ask students to work in groups to solve the problem then post several transparencies on the projector calling attention to correct solving methods and eventual errors. Always discuss the errors: why was that error made, what was the thinking process in the error as compared to the correct thinking process. Discuss what are the common mistakes students make in that type of problem.

3. Warm-ups: as students enter in class have a problem on the board/overhead to be solved. This will keep the attention focused, the class silent and bring the attention to the topic of study for the day. Ask for volunteers to put their responses on the board. A good way to keep everyone involved in by not asking for volunteers but randomly calling on students, this will make sure that everyone is working on the warm-up.

4. Group work: Put a multiple choice question on the board/overhead. The question should test understanding of a particular concept. Ask students to vote on the correct choice. This helps you determine whether or not more discussion is needed on that particular concept.


5. Practice and review
: Assign carefully chosen practice problems for homework, or for quiz. To keep students from simply doing the exercise for a correct answer ask questions that test their understanding “Explain what type of problem is this?” “Explain what type of concepts (or definitions or theorems or formulas) you need to use in order to solve this problem. Explain why is that the correct choice.” “Define variables that will help you to solve this problem. Describe what your first step will be.”

6. Interaction: Always use an interactive lecture style. When you ask a question (and that should be often!) pause long enough for students to think about the question and suggest an answer. Ask first the question and then call on random students. Do not jump to the next student if one does not know the correct answer. Give prompts, and help, ask the class to suggest a prompt NOT the correct response. Put only the conditions of a theorem on the board then turn to class and ask “What do you think we can conclude?”

Strategies to develop problem solving skills

Let students see: instead of posting on the overhead a ready solved problem solve it in front of your students. Talk thru the steps, and ask yourself questions so your students see how you think about solving that particular problem.
Ask questions: when solving problems ask questions. Pose a question and leave enough time for students to think about it. Some questions that fit any problem solving are:
- How do I start?
- What do I know?
- What formulas do I need to know here?
- Am I making sense?
- What are the possible approaches?
- What am I forgetting?
- Does this answer make sense?

Model strategies: model your process of thinking about how to solve a problem by talking it thru out loud. Another strategy is to present several problems of the same type then ask students to look for patterns.
Give credit for analysis: teach your students to explain their thinking process when they stumble in exam and give partial credit for explanation even if the result is not the correct one, if the student at least solves half way the problem and shows you the correct strategy of thinking give credit to your student for thinking about the problem.

Encourage thinking process evidence: if a student asks a question in class or via e-mail ask your student to explain his/her thinking process up to the point where they get stuck. It is not uncommon that students do not choose the appropriate approach and that is the reason why they do not find the solution, or might be they misunderstood up front the entire problem.
Provide focus: ask focused questions, give many problems of the same type so they have enough time to familiarize with one type of problem and practice solving skills.

Use small group work: post a problem on the board and ask students to turn to their neighbors or work in pairs and take turns thinking out loud while they solve a problem the other will monitor the process.

To increase student confidence and motivation use the following strategies:

Eliminate negativity: encourage your students to think about what they know and accept that everyone experiences at times lack of knowledge or strategies to solve problems. Do not allow generalized statements such as: “I am not good at this!” “I will never be good at this” “I will never be able to learn it”.
Be direct: especially when working with first year students warn them that if they were successful in high school that does not mean they do not work to work much harder in college. Explain them that college course level is different than high school and how that might be in your particular domain. Explain what exactly you expect. It is always good to have Student Learning Outcomes in your syllabus and explain them in detail at the first day of classes. Remind them again as semester goes on and as you introduce new topics. Student must be aware what do you expect from them, what kind of skills they must demonstrate by the time the course completes that particular topic.

Be personable: make an effort to know your students. Might be you will not learn all the names, but use all opportunity to know information related to the students in your class. A good idea is to use a short questionnaire in the first day of class by asking demographic questions. Tell them about your availability in office hours and encourage them to use the opportunity, a good idea is to come early to class so you can ask questions and chat about their interests. It makes you look more like a person and more approachable than the professor at the blackboard or behind a desk in the office. Share your out of class interests and ask them what are they interested in.

Communicate and encourage: Write notes on exams and quizzes, encourage them to come to your office if the performance is poor. Offer praise where you see success. They need your encouragement as well. If possible offer the chance to improve or retest. If too many fail a certain type of problem on an exam it is a sign most likely students did not understand the topic; give a quiz with the commonly missed problems – it is not fair to have so many fail because they did not understand the theory. Anytime the number of those who fail approaches 1/4th of class it is good to think about re-teaching the failed topic.

TAs in your large classes

TAs in your teaching team

Guidelines to set up the large class teaching by using a group of TAs:

1. Think broadly about training the teaching team
2. Recognize the different developmental stages among the TAs
3. Determine a clear organizational structure
4. Select and train the TAs
5. Communicate your expectations clearly
6. Evaluate across the semester the team work
7. Model teamwork and professional behavior

1. Think broadly about training the teaching team
- Emphasize a large definition of teaching which involves any interaction with students in the content of a course. Many times TAs think about “teaching” as standing up and lecturing. However the teaching work of a TA involves peer facilitation in working with small groups, organizing the class, dealing with discipline in the classroom, grading papers, responding to questions in office hours, responding and sending e-mails. Stress to your TAs that all work involving the course are in fact the different facets of teaching.

2. Recognize the different developmental stages among the TAs
- Consider the preparedness when making assignments for TAs. Those who have previous experience can handle more assignments and have many responsibilities compared to new TAs who need more guidance and instruction and help. Recognize that your TAs need different levels of structure, supervision, help, and guidance. Experienced TAs can take the role of teaching a lecture when new TAs feel uncomfortable even speaking in front of a small group.
- Be sensitive to age, gender, race, ethnicity aside of the teaching experience.

3. Determine a clear organizational structure
- Usually TAs share class responsibilities with the faculty member, assist the faculty in class organization, class materials, office visits, student e-mail, proctoring exams, grading papers and exams, peer facilitation, groups work coordination, lab work supervision, small section discussions, facilitate learning in break out sections and other problem solving activities.
- Decisions on organization and most appropriate structural model depends on department specifics, resources, functions that TAs need to fill, and particular faculty decisions in what concerns the course needs.

4. Select and train the TAs
- Selection and training of TAs is a very important part of working with TAs in small or large classes alike. No matter which organization model is used and what are the functions for each TA in the course several important criteria for TA selection are as following:
o Competency and direct experience with the course content
o Ability to work at different levels and in a team of instructors and TAs
o Ability to communicate with students
o Diversity of staff
o Willingness to participate in meetings, training, and weekly discussions with the instructors
- Per-semester training and Weekly meetings should provide TAs with details about the syllabus, class activities, student progress, grading issues
- A major topic for training the TAs should be concerning how to evaluate students work. A grading pan should be in place before the semester start. The use of a grading rubric is strongly advised. Using the grading rubric for the course TAs should be trained using some mock up student work so all TAs of a course be able to understand the grading requirements

5. Communicate your expectations clearly
- Always communicate high expectations for your course so that TAs understand that you are serious about your work. Involve the teaching team in setting the specific team work goals and interactions so they feel part of the team and that you are considering their needs
- Alleviate the concern that they should master perfectly the course content. Assure them that they have skills of working as a TA that you appreciate and that they have the expertise necessary and that they also learn in the process of being a TA
- If you have many TAs and also undergraduate peer facilitators it is good to set a clear structure. That will help in communication and also in the level of responsibility. For multiple TAs is always good to name a team coordinator (a TA with more experience) who will be the main contact person between you and the entire team. This way you could inform the team coordinator who will then make sure to deliver the information to the entire team, and vice versa.
- Use wiki password protected for your teaching team. There you will post the scoring rubrics for the exams, quizzes, homework and other assignments to be graded. Post on the wiki also at least one assignment that was graded by you so your TAs have a model. Post threads with your rationale when you grade the different parts. Explain in your own words your thinking process for each step of the grading rubric. In case you do not use a grading rubric then you MUST post detailed explanation about how you think when you grade an assignment. Allow your TAs to ask questions and post their reasoning on the wiki, keep a dialog and that will help the entire team and especially you (the faculty) to learn from present experience and improve your work with future teaching teams. Besides you can keep the same wiki across many semesters and improve it.

6. Evaluate across the semester the team work
- Feedback should be an ongoing part of team teaching. Your team will respond better if you stress developing versus performing, and learning versus knowing.
- Provide feedback and ask for feedback. Try to brainstorm with your team solutions to obstacles as well as to teaching goals.
- Ask everyone in your teaching team to encourage feedback from students.

7. Model teamwork and professional behavior
- You should present to the students from first day of classes your teaching team. All their names and information should be on the syllabus and they should be present in the first day. Involve them from the first day and stress to your students that you keep a close team work relationship with the teaching team and that you have weekly meetings.
- Provide diverse way to form and maintain team cohesion. It is important that student hear the same message from every member of the teaching team to not create confusion. If students observe that different TAs have different approaches or disagreements they will use these differences to create more confusion and discord in the classroom. For this reason weekly meetings and tight communication with your TAs is of major importance in teaching large classes.