Rate each criteria using the three point Likert scale:
1= Poor 2= Good 3= Excellent
Content: New information
Content:Usefulness
Content: Reference listed
Organization: Clarity and logical
Format: Appropriate for the audience
Aesthetic: Attractive and creative
Showing posts with label Teams. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Teams. Show all posts
Tuesday
Rubric for workshop (form 2)
Rate each criteria using the three point Likert scale:
1= Poor 2= Good 3= Excellent
The content was integrated and pertinent related to the topic assigned for the presentation
The content presented was going beyond the text book
The content presented had new and complex information
The content was presented in a clear and pertinent way
The content generated new ideas with real life application
The presentation helped the audience to apply the content to real life environment
The presentation was interesting and the activities progressed smoothly
The presenters displayed knowledge of the presented topics
The presenters involved the audience in discussions
The presenters responded in a knowledgeable manner to all questions
The presenters used creative modalities for presentation
The presenters conducted themselves in a professional manner
1= Poor 2= Good 3= Excellent
The content was integrated and pertinent related to the topic assigned for the presentation
The content presented was going beyond the text book
The content presented had new and complex information
The content was presented in a clear and pertinent way
The content generated new ideas with real life application
The presentation helped the audience to apply the content to real life environment
The presentation was interesting and the activities progressed smoothly
The presenters displayed knowledge of the presented topics
The presenters involved the audience in discussions
The presenters responded in a knowledgeable manner to all questions
The presenters used creative modalities for presentation
The presenters conducted themselves in a professional manner
Rubric for workshop (form 1)
Criteria-------- Points
Demonstrates an excellent understanding of key concepts; Writes clearly and logically; Shows and reflects on the relation between the concepts and topics; Grounded in the academic literature (use of citations and reference); Comprehensively addresses the topic; Includes descriptions, details, and personal examples for each major concept. Shows personal reflection on the theory; Different slides and topics present a continuous relation; Has reference or hyperlinks to the major concepts presented. Scholar presentation style, in the expressions used, grammar, and spelling. Excellent classroom applications with innovative techniques, good links to classroom activities
35-40
Demonstrates understanding of most key concepts; Generally writes clearly and logically; Acceptable support with resources (less academic literature more internet resources); Topics are presented sequential but weak presentation of comprehensive relationship between the major topics; Has references and hyperlinks for the majority of topics (but does not define and link major concepts), links are not with academic/scholar content (just a link on the web for the topic). Concepts are not presented (has a link to another web page for the reader); Has examples but they are short, not explained in detail, and with tangent relation to the topic. Does not explain the applications. Not careful in used expressions, grammar, and spelling.
28-34
Demonstrates limited understanding of key concepts; Careless writing, no comprehensive presentation of relation between the topics; Short and not comprehensive postings; Does not show the link between the major topics; Does not explain the major concepts but gives hyperlinks to web page for more info; Weak academic support with literature; Weak presentation of personal reflection on the theory; Rushed examples, mostly not personal examples (copied from text examples). Minimal real life application. Minimal references and hyperlinks. Not careful in used expressions, grammar, and spelling.
21-27
Mostly “just to do the job” slides; Short and disjointed remarks and writing; Concepts are not grounded in the academic literature; Disjointed presentation of topics; Only 1-2 hyperlinks or not at all. Lack of care in examples, or lack of examples over all. Topics are presented only as paraphrased from text, no personal reflection and does not show comprehensive understanding of the topics. Lack of real life applications. Sloppy expressions, grammar, and no care for the spelling.
20 or less
Demonstrates an excellent understanding of key concepts; Writes clearly and logically; Shows and reflects on the relation between the concepts and topics; Grounded in the academic literature (use of citations and reference); Comprehensively addresses the topic; Includes descriptions, details, and personal examples for each major concept. Shows personal reflection on the theory; Different slides and topics present a continuous relation; Has reference or hyperlinks to the major concepts presented. Scholar presentation style, in the expressions used, grammar, and spelling. Excellent classroom applications with innovative techniques, good links to classroom activities
35-40
Demonstrates understanding of most key concepts; Generally writes clearly and logically; Acceptable support with resources (less academic literature more internet resources); Topics are presented sequential but weak presentation of comprehensive relationship between the major topics; Has references and hyperlinks for the majority of topics (but does not define and link major concepts), links are not with academic/scholar content (just a link on the web for the topic). Concepts are not presented (has a link to another web page for the reader); Has examples but they are short, not explained in detail, and with tangent relation to the topic. Does not explain the applications. Not careful in used expressions, grammar, and spelling.
28-34
Demonstrates limited understanding of key concepts; Careless writing, no comprehensive presentation of relation between the topics; Short and not comprehensive postings; Does not show the link between the major topics; Does not explain the major concepts but gives hyperlinks to web page for more info; Weak academic support with literature; Weak presentation of personal reflection on the theory; Rushed examples, mostly not personal examples (copied from text examples). Minimal real life application. Minimal references and hyperlinks. Not careful in used expressions, grammar, and spelling.
21-27
Mostly “just to do the job” slides; Short and disjointed remarks and writing; Concepts are not grounded in the academic literature; Disjointed presentation of topics; Only 1-2 hyperlinks or not at all. Lack of care in examples, or lack of examples over all. Topics are presented only as paraphrased from text, no personal reflection and does not show comprehensive understanding of the topics. Lack of real life applications. Sloppy expressions, grammar, and no care for the spelling.
20 or less
Team Assignment--workshop
WORKSHOP & HANDOUT BROCHURE
Workshop (30 points)
Each student or pair of students (according to the number of students in the class) will develop a Power Point workshop (count it as length of maximum 50 minutes of class time) on a topic assigned for the date. The workshop will be based but should not repeat your textbook. That means you could choose the entire or a part of a topic, do a research related to that topic and develop it into a workshop by bringing in new and applied knowledge, but DO NOT repeat the information/content from the lecture (see power points for lecture) nor from the textbook (everyone in class is accountable to read the material from the text before coming to class). The goal of the workshop is to complete, and provide an integrated learning experience on the topic or part of the topic studied for that week. The workshop has as purpose the application to real life context of the respective content. Students will develop a power point, and a Brochure with the content presented (other information with reference to the internet, games, role play, panels, case studies, debates, audio and video methods, etc.). It is advised to develop activities that would involve as much possible your audience in the workshop process. Remember it is a workshop not a lecture or presentation! That is you have to integrate at least two activities to help your peers learn the topic you present. You have to give your colleagues new and innovative modalities of application of the content to real life. When you integrate the activities in the workshop you must specify for what exactly they can be used and the purpose why you use that activity. You also must show what are the cognitive processes used by the participants involved in that specific activity.
After class you are to post your Power point and Notes to the WORKSHOP forum by using a thread and attaching all documents to it, this way everyone will have access later in the semester to the material presented in class (just as you have access to my power point lectures). (Below see the brochure details)
Workshop evaluation rubric (see detailed rubric in separate document):
- Content coverage and meaning (Was the workshop integrated and pertinent related to the topic in study? Did the presenters display knowledge of the topic? Did the presenters respond in a knowledgeable manner to all questions?)
- New topic information (Was the content of the workshop going beyond the text book? Did it bring new and complex information pertaining to a college level audience?)
- Usefulness of content presented (Did the workshop help the audience to apply the content in a work related environment? Did the presenters involve the audience in discussions?)
- Creativity of presentation (Did the workshop generate new ideas that have real life application? Was the workshop interesting and did the activities progress smoothly? Did the workshop use creative modalities for presentation?)
- Clarity & professionalism (Did the presenters conduct themselves in a professional and sophisticated manner? Did the presenters present the material in a clear and pertinent way?).
Workshop handout brochure (10 points)
Each workshop will have as a result a handout (brochure) with the purpose to share the information of the workshop with members of the community you work in. The purpose of the brochure is to bring the information to other members of the community. For this reason your brochure needs to be explicit, complete as content, well organized, and creative in order to present in a pertinent and attractive way the information what you deliver. This is not an advertisement brochure but an informative brochure (your purpose is not to attract people to participate, but to provide a handout-like information for those who need the information for later time, and those who could not participate but would like to know the content).
The brochure should present all major information of the workshop, instructions for all activities, and ALL references used for the workshop.
Brochure rubric will include:
- Content: Was the flyer content appropriate and useful? Did it provide all reference?
- Organization: Was the flyer well organized, clear, and logical?
- Flow: Did all parts of the flyer fit together?
- Format: Was the flyer appropriate for non-practitioners?
- Aesthetic: Was the format of the flyer attractive and creative?
Please attach the brochure as a word document next to your power point and Notes of your power point, on the Blackboard Discussion board forums.
You will LOOSE points if the power point is not accompanied by the Notes (which otherwise can be written directly on the notes section of the power point!), or your Notes do not have enough details.
Please DO NOT overwhelm your power points with all details, keep it professional. Make all details part of the Notes section. Please describe in detail all activities that you would use in a real meeting session of your workshop! Your colleagues must be able to use each activity for future purposes.
-----------
EACH WORKSHOP WILL BE EVALUATED BY YOUR INSTRUCTOR AND ALL STUDENTS IN THE COURSE (except the ones who developed it).
Workshop (30 points)
Each student or pair of students (according to the number of students in the class) will develop a Power Point workshop (count it as length of maximum 50 minutes of class time) on a topic assigned for the date. The workshop will be based but should not repeat your textbook. That means you could choose the entire or a part of a topic, do a research related to that topic and develop it into a workshop by bringing in new and applied knowledge, but DO NOT repeat the information/content from the lecture (see power points for lecture) nor from the textbook (everyone in class is accountable to read the material from the text before coming to class). The goal of the workshop is to complete, and provide an integrated learning experience on the topic or part of the topic studied for that week. The workshop has as purpose the application to real life context of the respective content. Students will develop a power point, and a Brochure with the content presented (other information with reference to the internet, games, role play, panels, case studies, debates, audio and video methods, etc.). It is advised to develop activities that would involve as much possible your audience in the workshop process. Remember it is a workshop not a lecture or presentation! That is you have to integrate at least two activities to help your peers learn the topic you present. You have to give your colleagues new and innovative modalities of application of the content to real life. When you integrate the activities in the workshop you must specify for what exactly they can be used and the purpose why you use that activity. You also must show what are the cognitive processes used by the participants involved in that specific activity.
After class you are to post your Power point and Notes to the WORKSHOP forum by using a thread and attaching all documents to it, this way everyone will have access later in the semester to the material presented in class (just as you have access to my power point lectures). (Below see the brochure details)
Workshop evaluation rubric (see detailed rubric in separate document):
- Content coverage and meaning (Was the workshop integrated and pertinent related to the topic in study? Did the presenters display knowledge of the topic? Did the presenters respond in a knowledgeable manner to all questions?)
- New topic information (Was the content of the workshop going beyond the text book? Did it bring new and complex information pertaining to a college level audience?)
- Usefulness of content presented (Did the workshop help the audience to apply the content in a work related environment? Did the presenters involve the audience in discussions?)
- Creativity of presentation (Did the workshop generate new ideas that have real life application? Was the workshop interesting and did the activities progress smoothly? Did the workshop use creative modalities for presentation?)
- Clarity & professionalism (Did the presenters conduct themselves in a professional and sophisticated manner? Did the presenters present the material in a clear and pertinent way?).
Workshop handout brochure (10 points)
Each workshop will have as a result a handout (brochure) with the purpose to share the information of the workshop with members of the community you work in. The purpose of the brochure is to bring the information to other members of the community. For this reason your brochure needs to be explicit, complete as content, well organized, and creative in order to present in a pertinent and attractive way the information what you deliver. This is not an advertisement brochure but an informative brochure (your purpose is not to attract people to participate, but to provide a handout-like information for those who need the information for later time, and those who could not participate but would like to know the content).
The brochure should present all major information of the workshop, instructions for all activities, and ALL references used for the workshop.
Brochure rubric will include:
- Content: Was the flyer content appropriate and useful? Did it provide all reference?
- Organization: Was the flyer well organized, clear, and logical?
- Flow: Did all parts of the flyer fit together?
- Format: Was the flyer appropriate for non-practitioners?
- Aesthetic: Was the format of the flyer attractive and creative?
Please attach the brochure as a word document next to your power point and Notes of your power point, on the Blackboard Discussion board forums.
You will LOOSE points if the power point is not accompanied by the Notes (which otherwise can be written directly on the notes section of the power point!), or your Notes do not have enough details.
Please DO NOT overwhelm your power points with all details, keep it professional. Make all details part of the Notes section. Please describe in detail all activities that you would use in a real meeting session of your workshop! Your colleagues must be able to use each activity for future purposes.
-----------
EACH WORKSHOP WILL BE EVALUATED BY YOUR INSTRUCTOR AND ALL STUDENTS IN THE COURSE (except the ones who developed it).
Team persentations and workshops
Using team presentations and workshops
Using team presentations and workshops conducted by teams are good methods to help students develop team work skills, conduct team research, and involve the entire class in diverse activities.
I choose to word the two methods differently since I consider "presentations" to be what the word means in fact: a team (a person) will present the results of a completed work to a specific audience, usually followed by a Q & A section. This form is a very good one to help your students develop skills they will use for conference presentations, or interview.
"Workshops" are a type of presentation that along with presenting the results of a team/person's work will also involve the audience in several short activities to demonstrate briefly the application of the topic in discussion. Might involve testing, trying, building, brainstorming activities, etc.
The advantage of workshops over simple presentations is that the audience is more involved.
The disadvantage is that usually workshops require a longer time than a plain presentation.
Attached one model of using workshop as assignment in a course, as well as the Team workshop evaluation that will be used by the audience to evaluate the team presentation/workshop.
You (the instructor) also will complete the same "Team workshop evaluation" form -- of course your feedback might be more detailed than the one provided by the students in the class.
It is always a good exercise for your students to evaluate each other, that will keep their attention focused on the presentation, as well as give them one more skill by practicing good feedback.
There are two ways to use the team evaluation.
1. Ask the students in the audience to complete anonymous the evaluation; you complete the same form. Gather all the evaluations and after class read them all, staple yours on top, grade the presentation of the team; and next class time give the presenting team the entire package of feedback. In this case you measure only the team, and the evaluation done by the audience is only as an exercise in giving feedback to peers. The Learning Outcome for this should sound like this:
"Students will demonstrate the ability to sustain in class team presentations."
2. Ask the students in the audience to complete the evaluation form, and on the back of the sheet to write their own name. You will complete the same evaluation form. Gather all forms. Make copy of the front page (of the evaluation form) staple all together having on top your evaluation feedback. Next class time give the presenting team the entire package of feedback (with the copies of evaluation forms from the audience). Take all the original forms and sort them in pile by student names. Gather across the semester all original forms by student name. At the end of the semester revise the feedback provided by each student. Make sure in this case that a part of the grade is accounted for by the peer review of team presentations. The Learning Outcome for this should sound like this:
"Students will demonstrate the ability to provide critical feedback for peers who are involved in team presentations."
The first method works well even when you have a larger class (perhaps no more than 50). The second method (revising the peer feedback by individual student) works when you have small classes. It becomes very cumbersome and time consuming if you use the method for classes larger than 30 students.
In using this method explain your students that a good feedback is like a sandwich with three parts:
1. What was good
2. What needs to be improved.
3. Provide some ideas of how to improve the weak parts.
Using team presentations and workshops conducted by teams are good methods to help students develop team work skills, conduct team research, and involve the entire class in diverse activities.
I choose to word the two methods differently since I consider "presentations" to be what the word means in fact: a team (a person) will present the results of a completed work to a specific audience, usually followed by a Q & A section. This form is a very good one to help your students develop skills they will use for conference presentations, or interview.
"Workshops" are a type of presentation that along with presenting the results of a team/person's work will also involve the audience in several short activities to demonstrate briefly the application of the topic in discussion. Might involve testing, trying, building, brainstorming activities, etc.
The advantage of workshops over simple presentations is that the audience is more involved.
The disadvantage is that usually workshops require a longer time than a plain presentation.
Attached one model of using workshop as assignment in a course, as well as the Team workshop evaluation that will be used by the audience to evaluate the team presentation/workshop.
You (the instructor) also will complete the same "Team workshop evaluation" form -- of course your feedback might be more detailed than the one provided by the students in the class.
It is always a good exercise for your students to evaluate each other, that will keep their attention focused on the presentation, as well as give them one more skill by practicing good feedback.
There are two ways to use the team evaluation.
1. Ask the students in the audience to complete anonymous the evaluation; you complete the same form. Gather all the evaluations and after class read them all, staple yours on top, grade the presentation of the team; and next class time give the presenting team the entire package of feedback. In this case you measure only the team, and the evaluation done by the audience is only as an exercise in giving feedback to peers. The Learning Outcome for this should sound like this:
"Students will demonstrate the ability to sustain in class team presentations."
2. Ask the students in the audience to complete the evaluation form, and on the back of the sheet to write their own name. You will complete the same evaluation form. Gather all forms. Make copy of the front page (of the evaluation form) staple all together having on top your evaluation feedback. Next class time give the presenting team the entire package of feedback (with the copies of evaluation forms from the audience). Take all the original forms and sort them in pile by student names. Gather across the semester all original forms by student name. At the end of the semester revise the feedback provided by each student. Make sure in this case that a part of the grade is accounted for by the peer review of team presentations. The Learning Outcome for this should sound like this:
"Students will demonstrate the ability to provide critical feedback for peers who are involved in team presentations."
The first method works well even when you have a larger class (perhaps no more than 50). The second method (revising the peer feedback by individual student) works when you have small classes. It becomes very cumbersome and time consuming if you use the method for classes larger than 30 students.
In using this method explain your students that a good feedback is like a sandwich with three parts:
1. What was good
2. What needs to be improved.
3. Provide some ideas of how to improve the weak parts.
Team evaluation form
Team work evaluation form
Course____________________ Team__________________ Date__________________
Using the scale below please rate each of your team members according to the criteria in the below table:
0 = no show 1 = Weak 2 = Partial 3 = Good 4 = Excellent
Use the below grid to evaluate each team member by name:
(is much nicer if you build a table ---blogger does not let me do that)
________________________________
Evaluation criteria:
PREPARATION
Research, reading, and assignment completed
ATTENDANCE
On-time and stayed
for duration of meetings
PARTICIPATION
Contributed best
academic ability
INTERPERSONAL RELATIONS
Positive and productive
BETWEEN MEETING COMMUNICATION
Initiated and responded appropriately
TEAM CONTRIBUTION SCORE =
___________________________________________________________________________
Reflect on the following two Questions (optional if you would like to write your response)
1. What are the most important concepts you have learned from the Learning Team experience?
2. How will you use this learning to improve both personally and professionally?
Course____________________ Team__________________ Date__________________
Using the scale below please rate each of your team members according to the criteria in the below table:
0 = no show 1 = Weak 2 = Partial 3 = Good 4 = Excellent
Use the below grid to evaluate each team member by name:
(is much nicer if you build a table ---blogger does not let me do that)
________________________________
Evaluation criteria:
PREPARATION
Research, reading, and assignment completed
ATTENDANCE
On-time and stayed
for duration of meetings
PARTICIPATION
Contributed best
academic ability
INTERPERSONAL RELATIONS
Positive and productive
BETWEEN MEETING COMMUNICATION
Initiated and responded appropriately
TEAM CONTRIBUTION SCORE =
___________________________________________________________________________
Reflect on the following two Questions (optional if you would like to write your response)
1. What are the most important concepts you have learned from the Learning Team experience?
2. How will you use this learning to improve both personally and professionally?
Team agreement form
Team agreement form
Complete this form and keep a copy for your records and turn one copy to your instructor:
Course Title
Did all team members participate in the creation of this agreement form and agree with its contents?
Yes _____No _____
INSTRUCTOR
Course Dates
Team number (or name)
Team Member Information
Team member name / Email Address / Phone
(this is so that everyone in the team can reach you)
Team Member Strengths Inventory
List by team member name all skills, characteristics, and/or knowledge individual members can contribute to the productive work in the team
Conflict Management
Think about and list what are potential conflicts that might arise among or between team members during this course? How will team members deal with these conflicts? How will you make aware your instructor of any problems?
Ground Rules
Set your team work ground rules and list them below. Some examples might be: Do you agree to equally participate in all team work? Will you exchange phone numbers, and are calls OK, how late in the evening can your team members call you? Will you appoint weekly team leaders, or will you all contribute to each week’s assignment without having a leader? How will you deal if one team member does not participate in active work?
Complete this form and keep a copy for your records and turn one copy to your instructor:
Course Title
Did all team members participate in the creation of this agreement form and agree with its contents?
Yes _____No _____
INSTRUCTOR
Course Dates
Team number (or name)
Team Member Information
Team member name / Email Address / Phone
(this is so that everyone in the team can reach you)
Team Member Strengths Inventory
List by team member name all skills, characteristics, and/or knowledge individual members can contribute to the productive work in the team
Conflict Management
Think about and list what are potential conflicts that might arise among or between team members during this course? How will team members deal with these conflicts? How will you make aware your instructor of any problems?
Ground Rules
Set your team work ground rules and list them below. Some examples might be: Do you agree to equally participate in all team work? Will you exchange phone numbers, and are calls OK, how late in the evening can your team members call you? Will you appoint weekly team leaders, or will you all contribute to each week’s assignment without having a leader? How will you deal if one team member does not participate in active work?
Class introduction -- template
Class introductions
Please respond to the below questions. Responses will be read only by your instructor.
If you feel uncomfortable to respond to any of the below questions you may leave it blank.
Your First and Last name ____________________________________________________
Contact information: Where do you live? __________________________________________
e-mail_______________________________ phone #__________________________________
Academic major: _______________________________________________________________
Year of study _______________________
Grades in (any prerequisite course or a course related to what you teach) __________________
Gender (optional)__________________ Ethnicity (optional) ____________________________
Do you have a job aside of being a student? What do you work, and where?
______________________________________________________________________________
Please list the time blocks for days when you will NOT be able to work on team projects outside of class time:
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
What do you plan to be after you graduate? __________________________________________
Why? _______________________________________________________________________
- Favorite hobby? ______________________________________________________
- Favorite book or movie? ________________________________________________
- Favorite food or ice cream flavor? ________________________________________
Any interesting information about yourself you would like to share? __________________________________________________________________________
Please respond to the below questions. Responses will be read only by your instructor.
If you feel uncomfortable to respond to any of the below questions you may leave it blank.
Your First and Last name ____________________________________________________
Contact information: Where do you live? __________________________________________
e-mail_______________________________ phone #__________________________________
Academic major: _______________________________________________________________
Year of study _______________________
Grades in (any prerequisite course or a course related to what you teach) __________________
Gender (optional)__________________ Ethnicity (optional) ____________________________
Do you have a job aside of being a student? What do you work, and where?
______________________________________________________________________________
Please list the time blocks for days when you will NOT be able to work on team projects outside of class time:
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
What do you plan to be after you graduate? __________________________________________
Why? _______________________________________________________________________
- Favorite hobby? ______________________________________________________
- Favorite book or movie? ________________________________________________
- Favorite food or ice cream flavor? ________________________________________
Any interesting information about yourself you would like to share? __________________________________________________________________________
Using Teams in the Course
Often times when we use teams in a course we suppose that all students know already how to work in teams. However most often it is not the case!
A team is more than a group of students working together for class purposes. Teams are organized and goal oriented groups or 3-5 students working for a relative longer period of time completing together course assignments (as compared to small groups that in general work together for a class period on a small in-calss assignment). For this reason is it always a good idea for the instructor to form groups instead of allowing students to group together by friendships.
In order to form groups the instructor should explain students how they will work in teams across the semester and collect some information about the students in the first day of classes. A good explanation about forming teams instead of allowing self-grouping is that in the work force teams will be formed by skills or needs and not based on friendship (especially when is very possible the firends will work at another company). To make a good mix of skills and abilities in a team the instructor should ask some general questions:
- contact information
- academic major & year of study
- grades in any prerequisite courses
- times when the student is NOT available to work in team outside class
- if they have a job aside from being student
- area they live in (for grouping by closeness)
- gender (optional)
- ethnicity (optional)
- other questions such as: number of siblings, pets, favorite food, favorite sport, hobby, etc. These would help students share information that makes the acquintance less threatening.
Once the instructor collects the information sheet from everyone s/he can proceed to form teams. two major criteria should be kept as goal in team formation:
- to have a good mix of skills and abilities (by using the prerequisite course grade; or any other question that the instructor might like to use that taps into skills and abilities necessary for that course content).
- to have a balanced diversity in the team (using the responses to the gender and ethnicity questions; if a student did not respond to those questions then s/he will be randomly assigned to a team). Make sure you do not schedule intentional minorities in a team (e.g., only one female student, only one African American).
- as much possible keep track of the times they list as NOT begin able to meet and the Zone they live in. This is to avoid time conflicts or commuting issues.
The best advice is to have a list of team work expectations, guidelines to work in teams, and consequences of team disfunctionality in your syllabus. team work rules and policies can be set by the team members and stated in writing.
When using teams in your course is always good to ask your students to complete a Team Agreement Form, this will help all students in a team to exchange information and to set some basic rules of working in teams. As well as list any eventual consequences that the team members agree upon in case a team member does not complete the assigned task. The instructor should keep a copy of the team agreement form for future reference. In case of team work issues first always refer to the Team agreement form.
To make the team more cohesive is a good idea to ask students to pick a name for their team, as well as set roles for each member. The roles may change as tasks and semester evolves. make students aware that setting up roles will help them be more efficient as well as give them a clear structure in what concerns who needs to do what.
make students aware that the most usual conflicts in a team are related to the disfunctional roles such as: couch potatoes (let time go by), dominant leaders (listen to me I know better), hitchhikers (after not completing the work they claim how hard they worked and request the same grade), resistant members (my way or no way), divergent goal seakers ("I must get an A in this class" vs. "Who cares"). If you allow students to use the "firing rule" make sure you state it in your syllabus in detail -- the team can fire a member who does not contribute to the work; followed by the consequence that the fired member must find another team who will accept the person in their team; or have the fired person complete alone all other tasks and be grades based on that.
However is not enough only to help your students develop team working skills and set up some team work rules. It is very important that you, the instructor, measure the work each student put into the team work. You also must decide ahead of time what percentage of student grade in the course is based on team work. That should clearly be listed in the syllabus. Students should also have up front access to the rubric you will use to measure team work. You can choose many different criteria to evaluate team work. Is always good to take into consideration not only the content and presentation of final product, but also the process of work in teams (especially if your learning outcomes is listed as team work skills improvement).
For example to evaluate Teams you can ask your students to evaluate the presenting team and to complete this form: Team Work Evaluation Form.
Part of the grade should be accounted for by the way team members evaluate each other. Always explain them that you expect the evaluation to be professional; that means they will not develop a team agreement to evaluate maximally each other. If that is the case you will not be responsible in dealing with any issues that may arise in the team and you will not accept any complains about grading team members since in that case all members of that team will receive the same grade. In order to be able to grade individuals for team work you need their honest and critical feedback via the team evaluation form.
A team is more than a group of students working together for class purposes. Teams are organized and goal oriented groups or 3-5 students working for a relative longer period of time completing together course assignments (as compared to small groups that in general work together for a class period on a small in-calss assignment). For this reason is it always a good idea for the instructor to form groups instead of allowing students to group together by friendships.
In order to form groups the instructor should explain students how they will work in teams across the semester and collect some information about the students in the first day of classes. A good explanation about forming teams instead of allowing self-grouping is that in the work force teams will be formed by skills or needs and not based on friendship (especially when is very possible the firends will work at another company). To make a good mix of skills and abilities in a team the instructor should ask some general questions:
- contact information
- academic major & year of study
- grades in any prerequisite courses
- times when the student is NOT available to work in team outside class
- if they have a job aside from being student
- area they live in (for grouping by closeness)
- gender (optional)
- ethnicity (optional)
- other questions such as: number of siblings, pets, favorite food, favorite sport, hobby, etc. These would help students share information that makes the acquintance less threatening.
Once the instructor collects the information sheet from everyone s/he can proceed to form teams. two major criteria should be kept as goal in team formation:
- to have a good mix of skills and abilities (by using the prerequisite course grade; or any other question that the instructor might like to use that taps into skills and abilities necessary for that course content).
- to have a balanced diversity in the team (using the responses to the gender and ethnicity questions; if a student did not respond to those questions then s/he will be randomly assigned to a team). Make sure you do not schedule intentional minorities in a team (e.g., only one female student, only one African American).
- as much possible keep track of the times they list as NOT begin able to meet and the Zone they live in. This is to avoid time conflicts or commuting issues.
The best advice is to have a list of team work expectations, guidelines to work in teams, and consequences of team disfunctionality in your syllabus. team work rules and policies can be set by the team members and stated in writing.
When using teams in your course is always good to ask your students to complete a Team Agreement Form, this will help all students in a team to exchange information and to set some basic rules of working in teams. As well as list any eventual consequences that the team members agree upon in case a team member does not complete the assigned task. The instructor should keep a copy of the team agreement form for future reference. In case of team work issues first always refer to the Team agreement form.
To make the team more cohesive is a good idea to ask students to pick a name for their team, as well as set roles for each member. The roles may change as tasks and semester evolves. make students aware that setting up roles will help them be more efficient as well as give them a clear structure in what concerns who needs to do what.
make students aware that the most usual conflicts in a team are related to the disfunctional roles such as: couch potatoes (let time go by), dominant leaders (listen to me I know better), hitchhikers (after not completing the work they claim how hard they worked and request the same grade), resistant members (my way or no way), divergent goal seakers ("I must get an A in this class" vs. "Who cares"). If you allow students to use the "firing rule" make sure you state it in your syllabus in detail -- the team can fire a member who does not contribute to the work; followed by the consequence that the fired member must find another team who will accept the person in their team; or have the fired person complete alone all other tasks and be grades based on that.
However is not enough only to help your students develop team working skills and set up some team work rules. It is very important that you, the instructor, measure the work each student put into the team work. You also must decide ahead of time what percentage of student grade in the course is based on team work. That should clearly be listed in the syllabus. Students should also have up front access to the rubric you will use to measure team work. You can choose many different criteria to evaluate team work. Is always good to take into consideration not only the content and presentation of final product, but also the process of work in teams (especially if your learning outcomes is listed as team work skills improvement).
For example to evaluate Teams you can ask your students to evaluate the presenting team and to complete this form: Team Work Evaluation Form.
Part of the grade should be accounted for by the way team members evaluate each other. Always explain them that you expect the evaluation to be professional; that means they will not develop a team agreement to evaluate maximally each other. If that is the case you will not be responsible in dealing with any issues that may arise in the team and you will not accept any complains about grading team members since in that case all members of that team will receive the same grade. In order to be able to grade individuals for team work you need their honest and critical feedback via the team evaluation form.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)