Tuesday

Using Teams in the Course

Often times when we use teams in a course we suppose that all students know already how to work in teams. However most often it is not the case!

A team is more than a group of students working together for class purposes. Teams are organized and goal oriented groups or 3-5 students working for a relative longer period of time completing together course assignments (as compared to small groups that in general work together for a class period on a small in-calss assignment). For this reason is it always a good idea for the instructor to form groups instead of allowing students to group together by friendships.

In order to form groups the instructor should explain students how they will work in teams across the semester and collect some information about the students in the first day of classes. A good explanation about forming teams instead of allowing self-grouping is that in the work force teams will be formed by skills or needs and not based on friendship (especially when is very possible the firends will work at another company). To make a good mix of skills and abilities in a team the instructor should ask some general questions:

- contact information

- academic major & year of study

- grades in any prerequisite courses

- times when the student is NOT available to work in team outside class

- if they have a job aside from being student

- area they live in (for grouping by closeness)

- gender (optional)

- ethnicity (optional)

- other questions such as: number of siblings, pets, favorite food, favorite sport, hobby, etc. These would help students share information that makes the acquintance less threatening.



Once the instructor collects the information sheet from everyone s/he can proceed to form teams. two major criteria should be kept as goal in team formation:

- to have a good mix of skills and abilities (by using the prerequisite course grade; or any other question that the instructor might like to use that taps into skills and abilities necessary for that course content).

- to have a balanced diversity in the team (using the responses to the gender and ethnicity questions; if a student did not respond to those questions then s/he will be randomly assigned to a team). Make sure you do not schedule intentional minorities in a team (e.g., only one female student, only one African American).

- as much possible keep track of the times they list as NOT begin able to meet and the Zone they live in. This is to avoid time conflicts or commuting issues.



The best advice is to have a list of team work expectations, guidelines to work in teams, and consequences of team disfunctionality in your syllabus. team work rules and policies can be set by the team members and stated in writing.

When using teams in your course is always good to ask your students to complete a Team Agreement Form, this will help all students in a team to exchange information and to set some basic rules of working in teams. As well as list any eventual consequences that the team members agree upon in case a team member does not complete the assigned task. The instructor should keep a copy of the team agreement form for future reference. In case of team work issues first always refer to the Team agreement form.

To make the team more cohesive is a good idea to ask students to pick a name for their team, as well as set roles for each member. The roles may change as tasks and semester evolves. make students aware that setting up roles will help them be more efficient as well as give them a clear structure in what concerns who needs to do what.

make students aware that the most usual conflicts in a team are related to the disfunctional roles such as: couch potatoes (let time go by), dominant leaders (listen to me I know better), hitchhikers (after not completing the work they claim how hard they worked and request the same grade), resistant members (my way or no way), divergent goal seakers ("I must get an A in this class" vs. "Who cares"). If you allow students to use the "firing rule" make sure you state it in your syllabus in detail -- the team can fire a member who does not contribute to the work; followed by the consequence that the fired member must find another team who will accept the person in their team; or have the fired person complete alone all other tasks and be grades based on that.



However is not enough only to help your students develop team working skills and set up some team work rules. It is very important that you, the instructor, measure the work each student put into the team work. You also must decide ahead of time what percentage of student grade in the course is based on team work. That should clearly be listed in the syllabus. Students should also have up front access to the rubric you will use to measure team work. You can choose many different criteria to evaluate team work. Is always good to take into consideration not only the content and presentation of final product, but also the process of work in teams (especially if your learning outcomes is listed as team work skills improvement).

For example to evaluate Teams you can ask your students to evaluate the presenting team and to complete this form: Team Work Evaluation Form.

Part of the grade should be accounted for by the way team members evaluate each other. Always explain them that you expect the evaluation to be professional; that means they will not develop a team agreement to evaluate maximally each other. If that is the case you will not be responsible in dealing with any issues that may arise in the team and you will not accept any complains about grading team members since in that case all members of that team will receive the same grade. In order to be able to grade individuals for team work you need their honest and critical feedback via the team evaluation form.

Suggestions to write LO

Suggestions for Improving Statements of Learning Outcomes

1. Begin with statement of department or program purpose, linked to the College's mission

2. Use active voice. For example: Students develop familiarity, NOT students will become familiar.

3. Specify and explicate broadly drawn expectations such as understand, develop, appreciate. Think about the expectations in terms of thresholds: how would you know if a student understands or appreciates? Alternatives might include the following: know, recognize, describe, use, demonstrate. The learning outcomes must be measurable. All assessment used in courses should be measures of the Learning outcomes.

4. Describe expectations positively (as a necessity) rather than conditionally: students should be able to; better: students will be able to . . . .

5. Identify the most central student learning expectations rather than a laundry list of possible expectations. Learning outcomes and assessments used should pair. The reasons you use the assessment in your course is in fact because you want to measure the learning outcomes.

6. It may be useful to distinguish lower level expectations from higher level expectations, using Blooms taxonomy. The next step in the process is to describe learning experiences that allow students to meet the expectations.


Below several examples collected from across the web:

Example 1:
Students will understand the fundamental principles;
better: Students will be able to describe the fundamental principles

Example 2:
Students will develop essential thinking and problem solving skills;
better: students will be able to demonstrate thinking and problem solving skills in specific ways .

Example 3:
Students will be introduced to major figures;
better: students will recognize and will be able to discuss the writings of major figures

Example 4:
The concentration provides comprehensive exposure to a range of topics;
better: students study diverse topics and will be able to describe the issues and use the methods of the field

Example 5:
Courses provide comparative analyses;
better: students read, write, and practice theoretical approaches and will be able to discuss their critical understandings of the respective strengths and weaknesses of those approaches

Example 6:
Students are expected to understand fundamental conceptual and theoretical propositions;
better: students will be able to describe fundamental conceptual and theoretical propositions

Example 7:
Students comprehend;
better: Students will be able to describe

Example 8: Students are taught the forms . . .;
better: Students will know and will be able to describe

EXAMPLE Learning Outcomes for group work in a course:

On completion of the course, students will have demonstrated their ability to:
- communicate effectively, both orally and in writing, with other group members during the project and in the presentation of the individual and group outcomes of the project
- develop, monitor and continually update a plan for personal contribution to the group project
- negotiate, adopt, review and comment critically on the personal role taken within the group and exercise leadership within that role
- work effectively, in a variety of roles, as part of a team, exercising independence and leadership when appropriate
- identify and apply appropriate quantitative and qualitative tools to elicit a client’s needs and to create innovative solutions to those needs
- elicit and transform a set of customer requirements into a specification for an engineering system to meet an identified need
- collect, critically evaluate and use information from a wide variety of sources to generate a range of solutions to the problems defined, and identify and use suitable criteria to select a single solution for further development
- evaluate the outcomes of the project against the original needs using suitable social, environmental, ethical, economic and commercial measures of performance.


To measure the above learning outcomes students are assessed through a combination of:
- team reports on the design and development task the team undertakes
- oral and poster presentations of the project at a residential event
- personal reflection by the student on their effectiveness as a member of the team

Examples of learning outcomes

Examples of Learning Outcomes:

• Understands integral and differential calculus and uses them in problem solving
"Understand" is not an action word and does not describe what students will be able to do differently as a result of the course. A better outcome might be: “Applies concepts of integral and differential calculus to solve industrial and management engineering problems”

• Express numbers in scientific notation using the correct number of significant digits.
This statement describes a discrete skill, but not an overarching goal of a class. A better outcome might be: “Express and manipulate numbers effectively using the concepts of scientific notation, significant digits, and SI unit measurements.”

• Is able to apply learned information to projects.
Even though the statement talks about ability of applying information does not show exactly how that ability will be measured. A better outcome would be: “Formulates an experimental plan of data gathering to attain a stated objective (develop correlation, test a model, ascertain performance of equipment, etc.).”

• Develops a design strategy, including a plan of attack, decomposition of work into subtasks, development of a timetable. Suggests new approaches and improves on what has been done before. Develops several potential solutions and finds optimum.
This statement meets all the criteria.

• Is able to ientify unknown bacteria using gram stain, biochemical, and other microbiological methods for identification.
This statement meets all the criteria.

• Appreciate the difference between various forms of graphical representation.
This statement is vague and is not measurable. A better outcome might be: “Given a set of data, construct a time series, scatterplot, or histogram to show relationships between quantities.”

• The student has good writing skills.
This statement is too vague to be measurable. A better outcome might be: “Articulates ideas clearly and concisely. Organizes written materials in a logical sequence to enhance the reader's comprehension (paragraphs, subheading, etc.).”




Comparison of a syllabus in two formats: Content based and Learning Outcomes based.

Content based Syllabus

COURSE DESCRIPTION
This course teaches the fundamentals of Educational Psychology. The course covers diverse learning theories, classroom management, and classroom assessment techniques.
We will cover the aspect of human learning as imbedded in contextual factors such as SES, gender, culture, etc. (A typical content-focused course description lists the topics covered in the course, but does not include what the students will do or what is expected of them they will be able to demonstrate by the end of the course.)

COURSE GOAL
The purpose of this course is to provide the fundamentals of human learning and methods that teachers can use to measure the learning process in the classroom setting. (The goal focuses on the instructor since the instructor will provide the information. In fact shows what the instructor will do)

COURSE OBJECTIVES
1. To explain how the human mind learns.
2. To understand the different learning theories.
3. To illustrate the relationships between learning and assessment.
4. To learn different methods of classroom assessment.
5. To understand the different classroom management techniques by applying diverse learning theories
(These course objectives are again content oriented and list in fact the major topics that will be studied in the course. They show what the student will learn, and what the instructor will explain.)


Learning Outcomes based syllabus

COURSE DESCRIPTION
This course will enable students to gather information about several human learning theories. The students will be able to plan classroom management and assessment methods for a hypothetical classroom they were to teach. (This course description does not list the course content and topics to be studied, but describes what the student will be able to do upon successful completion of the course)

COURSE THEMES
Learning theories, classroom management and assessment techniques. (These are the themes addressed in the course.)

LEARNING OUTCOMES
When the students have successfully completed this course they will be able to:
- compare, contrast, and describe the similarities and differences of the learning theories presented in this course.
- critique the strengths and weaknesses of each learning theory as applied to diverse classroom management techniques.
- design and plan for different classroom management techniques according to the cognitive characteristics of learners they would teach and the specific learning theory used.
- use and craft appropriate assessment methods according to the learning theory used in teaching and the cognitive level that was planned to be assessed. (all learning outcomes show what the student will be able to do with the knowledge upon successful completion of the course)

How to write LO for your syllabus

Worksheet to write Learning Outcomes
for course purposes when you already have a well set course with an existent syllabus.


Start from the existent syllabus and follow the steps below:

1. List all the assessment methods you use in the course (quiz, test, project, team work, homework assignments, etc.)

2. Think about the goals and reasons you choose that particular assessment method in what concerns the measurement of student learning

3. Derive from the above and write sentences describing what type of student learning will the assessment measure. That is what it is that the students actually do to receive the grade. In the sentence the subject will be the student, and the verb will be the descriptor of the knowledge, ability, skill, behavior, etc. that the student will demonstrate through the respective assessment. (e.g., Students will be able to compare and contrast in writing the theory of X with theory Y; Students will understand and be able to write about important questions in XYZ; Students will be able to think critically and create solutions to problems based on learned content. Students will recall the content and make inferences on key important points. Students will be able to select correct interpretations and solutions to conceptual problems.)

4. These sentences are the learning outcomes which should be listed in the syllabus under the heading “Learning Outcomes.” The learning outcomes and the assessments used in each course should always match.

If, after having gone through this procedure, you are not happy with the list, the chances are good that you are not testing the students on the things you want them to know.


Some guidelines for writing Learning Outcomes are below:


When writing the learning outcomes:

• A good start is to use Bloom’s Taxonomy to guide you in planning the teaching and assessment so that is at all levels of thinking and knowledge
• Use action verbs that show measureable performance
• 4 to 8 sentences are reasonable for a course or program, since the Learning Outcomes must be listed in the syllabus
• Write the sentences in a language that students (and those outside the field) are able to understand
• Usually Learning Outcomes are not content specific (that means they do not describe the topics/content the students will learn in the course)
• The outcomes should focus on the overarching concepts, skills, abilities, behaviors, or attitudes that students will present at the end of the course
• Most important the Learning Outcomes must be measurable, assessable and should imply an assessment (they must match the assessment used in that course to measure student learning), however it should not be too specific to give flexibility in case different instructors teach sections of the same course (the learning outcomes should be the same but the teaching methods and assessment possibly differs from one instructor to the other; in the end students must have the same skills once they complete the course not matter who is the instructor)
• A good rule of thumb is to NOT use in the sentence verbs such as “remember”, “understand”, “learn”, “know”, “have an idea about…” etc. because these verbs indicate internal mental processes --- unless the assessment measures only that --- and on Bloom’s Taxonomy they are represented as lower levels of thinking. Instead use verbs that describe what students will be able to do, produce, or demonstrate. Be sure that you can measure what outcomes you set.

NFL --- template

NFL game

(very good to use when you have a summer course when the NFL games are at the same time, or if you want to use it as an "ice breaker" for a very hard topic)


Think about what you learned in this class and respond shortly to the questions below:

List what is the New concept you learned:




The concept you feel comfortable on teaching your Friend:





Which topic you need to do more Learning:




------------
Author of “NFL game”: Zsuzsanna Szabo, Ph.D.